Fiat 500 Fit For Full-Timers?

Our new Fiat 500

Our new Fiat 500

We drove a new 2013 Fiat 500 over 1,000 miles this past week.  Some of you might wonder if it has the required towing capacity for our 6,500 pound trailer.  No.  I’ll get back to that later.  The Fiat 500 is a more economical means for travel between a couple of points than driving our big red truck.

picture of driver side of our red truck

Our big red truck

We usually drive the big red truck.  It’s a fully capable trailer towing machine and equipped with more amenities and electronics than any vehicle either of us ever owned.  Comfortable?  You bet.  Big?  A bit. Expensive to drive?  Definitely!  Last week we needed to make a road trip between Dayton OH and Charlotte NC. Luckily, Jim’s brother suggested we consider renting a car — both fun and economical, he said.

The quick rundown showed we would save over $50 on gas costs alone after paying the rental fees.  Little did we know we would be driving this cute little looker AND getting great economy. Including all costs we might have saved hundreds of dollars using this little gas sipper instead of taking our truck the 1,000 miles round trip.

Here’s a quick look at some statistics between this Fiat 500 and our 2006 Chevy 2500HD truck:

1,400 cc engine instead of 8,100 cc engine.
2,800 pounds loaded vs 8,000 pounds loaded.
Total interior volume 85 cf vs 140 cf+.
40 liters gas tank instead of 45 gallons.
41 mpg highway vs 15 mpg highway.
Horsepower and Torque ratings of 100/98 vs 330/455
Towing capacity of ZERO vs 16,000 pounds
$17,500 instead of $43,000.

Why are the dreamstreamrs road testing the Fiat 500? We needed to drive from Dayton OH to Charlotte NC and back for a weekend. This 1,000 mile round trip is almost all highway but still could cost a lot in our big red truck. The 4X4 truck’s 496 ci (8.1 liter) engine and 8,000 pound weight are all about capability, not economy. Jim’s brother suggested we consider renting a car — it’s fun to drive something different plus we could probably do it cheaper than in our truck.

The Enterprise rental agency in Centerville OH pulled our rental car to the front while we were inside doing rental paperwork Thursday morning. Their sample sub-compact is a Chevy Aveo. We were delighted to walk out and find a little white Fiat 500 smugly awaiting our approval.

Fiat Co brought this model to the states in 2012. We had read the early reviews with interest, hoping to find they had brought a true economy car. Too often, it has seemed to us, car manufacturers have withheld from the American market small gas misers because Americans “would not purchase under-powered cars”.

True to form, the reviews often cite the Fiat 500’s low power (98 hp) as the car’s major short-coming. Two interstate days of 500+ miles each and two days of urban driving proved the car has enough power to maintain highway speed despite our loading the boot fully with our gear for this trek.

This car is seriously cute inside and out. We didn’t measure but the Fiat 500 looks as though it would fit into the bed of our truck, maybe an Eddie Bauer extended Airstream, or surely into a Pan American Airstream.

controls nicely arranged

controls nicely arranged

The interior is fun and nicely arranged. Fiat’s designers cleverly decluttered the controls. Some of the functions were intuitive, where you might expect to find them and operating similarly to what we are accustomed to. The a/c compressor is switched on or off by pressing in on the fan control’s rotary switch. Smart, simple, and clean. Neat design.

A few controls were a little more interesting to fathom. Last night Jim accidentally stumbled on the headlight delay switch (on the hi-beam/turn signal stalk). The door locks by pressing the door latch into the bodywork. The seats recline and release for folding with a handle at the top corner of each seat.

Speaking of seats, we found the seats very comfortable for driving, but think these are small person seats. Tremendous leg room suggests tall sizes are welcome, but the seats are the narrowest we’ve seen in a car. The driver’s seat cushion easily adjusts up and down, nice for varying leg position.

Seating position is good. The driver’s arms are extended to reach the steering wheel, and all controls visible and easy to reach. Good visibility overall, particularly side and forward. The radio requires a little practice but worked well and sounded good through the six speakers.

The Fiat 500 is surprisingly quiet, smooth, and comfortable on the long stretches of interstate driving. We expected a rougher ride from a very short car. Handling doesn’t seem great, the car doesn’t inspire a lot of confidence in turns. Maybe a different tires setup or (I hate to suggest) more power would improve cornering?

One of the greatest joys was hitting parking spaces with this little car. The mirrors are good and visibility at the front is great, so pulling in, backing, and parallel parking are all a breeze. It seems you could parallel into a space no longer than a living room sofa.

an hour of I-77 in NC

an hour of I-77 in NC

How did we do on economy? The rental cost was $25/day with unlimited mileage. We rented the car five days, or $125. We saved enough on gas costs to pay the entire rental fee. Our gas mileage was 25 mpg BETTER than our truck, so we saved over forty gallons of gas by not driving our truck for this 1,000 mile trip.

Assuming AAA’s April 2013’s $0.773/ mile total vehicle cost, we might have saved over $650 net by leaving our truck parked for this quick trip. AND we had a lot of fun driving this cute and comfortable little car. Thanks brother Chuck for the great cost-saving idea.

Sad Fiat

Sad Fiat

How about safety on the Fiat 500 — how is it in crashes? We had the misfortune to find out when a fellow started to turn left smack in front of us, failed to yield to oncoming traffic. There was nowhere for us to go, and despite how slow we were going, he pulled across too late for us to avoid his car. The Fiat is pretty much a mess.

Airbags deployed everywhere

Airbags deployed everywhere

The Fiat 500 deployed all its air bags, destroying both front seats and the windshield. The impact damaged the bumper, both fenders, both doors. The noise of the airbags was deafening, the smell slightly like burnt wiring, the car was instantly very hot inside, and some sort of cornstarch powder filled the air.

The passenger side dash airbag broke the windshield. The wrecker guys said this is common, for the airbag to “use” the windshield as a backstop.

The car’s body panels don’t fit too well anymore. Sort of a surprise to us, considering how slow we were going just before impact.

Jim checks with other driver

Jim checks with other driver

The other guy seemed to have no injury at all. We think we have only a couple of bruises and a bunch of burns between us. The bags seemed to have protected us pretty completely except for cuts on our legs from under the dash.

and then the wrecker truck tire blows

and then the wrecker truck tire blows

The wrecker truck picked up our rental car and us two hours after the incident to take all to Cincinnati where we could pick up another car and continue to Dayton. But the wrecker suffered a blown tire and stopped us AGAIN. Thankfully our good Dayton friends were already on their way toward Cincinnati and detoured to our road stop. They carried us home with them.

Our trip westward will wait another day while we try to sort out the impacts from this incident. The Fiat? Maybe a one hit wonder, but a great little car still.

See you down the road!

Jim and Debbie

locate us here
visit our website

©2007-2013 Dreamstreamr

13 responses to “Fiat 500 Fit For Full-Timers?

  1. Richard Hunt

    Thanks for the road test report, Jim. Those in the magazines don’t usually give crash reports on the airbag deployment. We are glad you two are well after the accident. We really like our Yukon Hybrid as our only car. Not only does it tow our 25′ really well, but is not as punitive with not pulling. Now that we are at Travelers Rest, I am considering a second vehicle. It would be nice to have a Chevy Spark or such for trips into town. The priority purchase most likely will be a golf cart for enjoying the vastness of the RV resort. Keep safe!

  2. With the crash report, this was one of the most thorough test reports I’ve read! You put Automobile Magazine to shame. Glad you are both OK!

  3. Wrecking the car shows true dedication to the pursuit of valid automobile information! Well done! ;-)
    Glad you’re OK, too.
    That Fiat is probably totaled. Those airbags are expensive, but cheaper than hospital bills. Drive safely…

    • Bells are going off throughout our trailer, celebrating our 1,000th comment! (excludes the 10,929 spam comments, by the way) Thanks for being our lucky 1,000th commenter, Rich.

      About our dedication — you, Bob, and Richard all reflected on our going all the way for our readers on this road test. Just joking about the following, are there a lot of product manufacturers needing our services. We should be hearing from Molly at Airstream any moment, asking if we will show the same dedication for our favorite brand. Wouldn’t that be an intriguing road test? How would we test a Keurig coffee machine to death? Or maybe Apple computers. We’ll need some time to develop our marketing plan for these possibilities. Not.

      On a serious note, we are surprised at lingering effects from the Jun 3 crash. We are tired, noticeably below our normal energy level. And we’re not exactly nervous, but driving from Dayton to Kickapoo State Park in Illinois yesterday just didn’t have the same warm fuzzy feel we’ve grown accustomed to. The thrill of the tires singing and the engine humming as we pull our home down the road, it just wasn’t there yesterday.

      We’re taking a zero day today before we head westward into Iowa on our way to Huron. Striving for 200 miles, two nights, off the road by 2pm. And maybe two gin and tonics each afternoon.

      It was great seeing you and E and E at Alumapalooza. Next year, hopefully, we can stay the duration.

  4. I have a Fiat 500C…it’s a superb little car. Sorry to hear about your accident, glad you got out unscathed.

    • Thanks lazybill. Does the 500C mean it’s a convertible? We completely agree with you about how nice a car it is, and still think we would gladly buy one. Just yesterday we saw our first gray one. In Hollywood FL in March we saw a customized Abarth model. The Pop1 like we rented was just fine for us. Maybe some day . . .

      • Yes, ‘C’ for convertible and it’s been great to drive this week as summer has finally arrived in the UK!

  5. The ambulance chasers are looking for us. Someone called us, let us know unsolicited and unwanted mail is piling up. We won’t bother counting the number of pieces — we’ll just burn it all. If we felt compelled to fight, such as to regain the $1,000 deductible we paid to the rental car company, rest assured we would not select an ally from the host who sent us “work wanted” mail. Should we publicly post a list of the ambulance chasers firms’ names?

  6. Nah, don’t bother. People look to sue on your behalf are a dime a dozen. But check any vehicle, umbrella or homeowners insurance policies you have to see if they might cover the deductible on a rental car loss. Hopefully you won’t be out the $1000 for long.

    • The deductible is on our own liability coverage and we contracted with rental car company to give it to them if we didn’t pay their daily insurance coverage rip-off. We heard today from driver 1’s insurance who has promised to expeditiously return our out of pocket expense. Life is great and we are healing. Thanks for your helpful words.

  7. Stephen Loden

    Thanks Jim for the report….I believe we will stick with our 1 Ton Ford F-350 Dually and bite the bullet at the Fuel Stops.

    • Steve and Marty,
      Two points in favor of the truck — could anyone claim, “I didn’t see it coming”, and if someone did get in front of your truck it wouldn’t be so much a two vehicle collision but a train wreck — I’d hate to be on the receiving end of that. I’ll stay out of collisions if you will — let’s make our trucks last a long time. Enjoyed talking on the phone with you yesterday, too. thx for calling.

  8. Pingback: Why We Love Our Truck | Dreamstreamr Odyssey

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.